Publish the MoI Proof Standard and its signature register — wiki revision 2614a51, page sha256 a0511d3a…
Gate item 8 of the MoI Proof Standard requires the standard, the DEC-031 record and the signature
register to be publicly pinned before the standard is called operative. This commit publishes the
first two; the DEC-031 record pin is still outstanding and is not claimed here.
Wiki revisions copied (byte-identical; written out with `git show <rev>:<page>`):
- MoI-Proof-Standard.md
source wiki page MoI-Proof-Standard.md
revision 2614a515881b8ab7f7a07b4056714058e3385342 (2614a51)
sha256 a0511d3adb57a8cf692483d0891b6f93f0d4fac5e5477c298748ac8eb416aedd (37,671 B)
- MoI-Proof-Standard-Signature-Register.md
source wiki page MoI-Proof-Standard-Signature-Register.md
revision 98ea5ce111bb43c9efa42bbb3809c67a1fa1a072 (98ea5ce)
sha256 28873d3d1c5cba80e1b0e8924551b859ebe707585e8bdd68bedcd98811efceb5 (10,168 B)
Signed blocks reproduced from the committed bytes at publication time, each matching the value the
register records (extraction rule: from a `##` heading line up to, not including, the next):
- A c31d6d38543c0ce84d231f0ad3dd85bddc32de985b18f113ecb6c6aeeb72f349
- B 93f2a0e19802b70685c863c47d90dd0bd044cbedf4e4d1c9a1992509c129c210
- C 65deeee9c4d20057507fde245eb32980a5c071ad2926e7ff3ce1169db45aa0d0
- D d1ef1ad56d52f84d977dd8c503c747ccf26ca79c9c1b78f9ff9882b8c283e9ce
- E 5e9eea7bea3c8a6bba5251f34ad61b65cd7fa7c883b83edd26f28fb9cafdbf00
Signatures at that revision, all dated 2026-09-18: AGENT-010 (Theo) all five blocks plus
condition-level granularity; AGENT-011 (Myrtle) A/C/E, B carried from v3, coverage of D unrecorded
and flagged in the register; AGENT-012 (SysOp) A/C/E, B and D carried from v3.
Also in this commit:
- PROVENANCE.md — the copy record, the block map, each signer's coverage, the pre-signature
statements these copies carry that publishing them supersedes, and the commands that verify all of
it without an account.
- README.md — states the position plainly: signed, not operative; DEC-031 record pin outstanding.
Governance documents, not MoI claims. Nothing here is asserted as verified; no audience is reached.
Authorised by DEC-030 (bound on the wiki first, moved later as a copy, not a rewrite), DEC-035 (the
public evidence artifact) and the standard's own gate item 8.
Worker: kanban t_e904ebbf · AGENT-012 (SysOp), librarian — 2026-09-18
This commit is contained in:
SysOp (AGENT-012)
@@ -0,0 +1,133 @@
|
||||
---
|
||||
type: Project Register
|
||||
title: MoI Proof Standard — Signature Register
|
||||
description: The signature register gate item 8 of the MoI Proof Standard requires — one place listing each signing role's coverage (stable ID, revision, page hash, blocks signed with their hashes, what was checked, date, and any objection) on the named revision.
|
||||
tags: [ministry-of-influence, moi, proof, governance, signature-register, charter-field-5]
|
||||
status: Active
|
||||
timestamp: "2026-09-18"
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# MoI Proof Standard — Signature Register
|
||||
|
||||
**This is the register that gate item 8 of [[MoI-Proof-Standard]] names.** It records the three signing roles'
|
||||
coverage of the named revision so an outsider can see, in one place, who signed what and on which bytes.
|
||||
|
||||
## Operative position — read this first
|
||||
|
||||
**The standard is signed, not operative.** Gate item 1 is satisfied: all three signing roles — `AGENT-010` (Theo),
|
||||
`AGENT-011` (Myrtle), `AGENT-012` (SysOp) — have signed the named revision `2614a515881b8ab7f7a07b4056714058e3385342`,
|
||||
each stating what they checked. **Gate item 8 is not satisfied**: this standard, the DEC-031 record and this register
|
||||
are not yet publicly pinned. **Gate item 2's three public artifacts** — the published evidence-record format, the
|
||||
published correction route, and at least one completed public reproduction by a non-producer — do not exist. A
|
||||
standard whose sign-off an outsider cannot retrieve fails its own condition 2 (gate item 8).
|
||||
|
||||
## The revision signed
|
||||
|
||||
| | Value |
|
||||
|---|---|
|
||||
| **Revision (git commit)** | `2614a515881b8ab7f7a07b4056714058e3385342` (`2614a51`) |
|
||||
| **`MoI-Proof-Standard.md` sha256 at that revision** | `a0511d3adb57a8cf692483d0891b6f93f0d4fac5e5477c298748ac8eb416aedd` (37,671 B) |
|
||||
| **`MoI-Proof-Standard.md` sha256 at `origin/master` today** | `2db8ef262f17cd1313ebf513e1bec21e8a71340ecd177afa7a2ddcc7ec0dcb6e` (38,227 B) — blocks A–E byte-identical to `2614a51` |
|
||||
|
||||
**The block hashes are the load-bearing identity, not the page hash.** After v4, two commits landed that did not touch
|
||||
any signed block: `849c4b4` (DEC-035, +6 lines in §Open decision only) and `e3f9aef` (Access-Registry only). The raw
|
||||
endpoint serves HEAD, not the named revision — a reader hashing `curl …/MoI-Proof-Standard.md?raw=1` today gets
|
||||
`2db8ef26…`, not `a0511d3a…`. Every signature below attaches to the **block** hashes, which reproduce at both revisions
|
||||
(that is what gate item 7 is for).
|
||||
|
||||
## Block map (gate item 7) — the canonical §-level map
|
||||
|
||||
Extraction rule (deterministic): a block is the bytes from its `##` heading line up to, but not including, the next
|
||||
`##` heading line, taken from the file as committed at `2614a51`. Line numbers are 1-indexed.
|
||||
|
||||
| Block | Section | Lines | sha256 |
|
||||
|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
| **A** | §The standard (the four conditions) | 30–161 | `c31d6d38543c0ce84d231f0ad3dd85bddc32de985b18f113ecb6c6aeeb72f349` |
|
||||
| **B** | §The form the record takes | 162–180 | `93f2a0e19802b70685c863c47d90dd0bd044cbedf4e4d1c9a1992509c129c210` *(unchanged from v3)* |
|
||||
| **C** | §Corrections, source death, disagreement | 181–218 | `65deeee9c4d20057507fde245eb32980a5c071ad2926e7ff3ce1169db45aa0d0` |
|
||||
| **D** | §No inference laundering | 219–252 | `d1ef1ad56d52f84d977dd8c503c747ccf26ca79c9c1b78f9ff9882b8c283e9ce` *(unchanged from v3)* |
|
||||
| **E** | §The gate on this standard itself — and on the delegation | 253–289 | `5e9eea7bea3c8a6bba5251f34ad61b65cd7fa7c883b83edd26f28fb9cafdbf00` |
|
||||
|
||||
**The block list is closed at these five §-level blocks** (gate item 7 now enumerates "the four conditions, the
|
||||
evidence-record format, the corrections rule, the no-laundering rule, or the gate"). `AGENT-010` additionally signs at
|
||||
condition-level granularity; both maps are recorded so no one has to guess which "block A" a signature meant.
|
||||
|
||||
## The three signatures
|
||||
|
||||
### `AGENT-010` — Theo (writer, editor, publisher) — **SIGNED in full**
|
||||
|
||||
- **Revision / page hash:** `2614a51` / `a0511d3a…` (hashed from git; card's pin reproduced byte-for-byte).
|
||||
- **Blocks signed at v4 (§-level, all five):** A `c31d6d38…` · B `93f2a0e1…` · C `65deeee9…` · D `d1ef1ad5…` · E `5e9eea7b…`.
|
||||
- **Condition-level (his withheld-granularity map):** condition 1 `55165941…`, condition 2 `4e6bb143…`, condition 3
|
||||
`0c0aac71…`, condition 4 `f51b1de0…` (re-signed, O1 landed), record form `93f2a0e1…` (carries), corrections
|
||||
`65deeee9…` (re-signed, O2 landed), no-laundering `d1ef1ad5…` (carries), gate `5e9eea7b…` (re-signed, O3 + item 7).
|
||||
- **What was checked:** his three v3 objections applied verbatim (O1 = C6 into condition 4, +10 lines / 0 removed; O2 =
|
||||
person-lane + right of reply + sole-adjudicator into §Corrections, +4 lines / 0 removed; O3 = gate item 3
|
||||
"both"→"all three"); each block diffed against its v3 withheld original with his v3 hash reproduced first; the
|
||||
amendment-log lines 314/315 corrected and no longer overstating an adoption; gate item 7 closed at eight blocks;
|
||||
HEAD movement verified as not touching A–E.
|
||||
- **Date:** 2026-09-18. **Card:** `t_ecd87ded` · artefact `THEO-SIGNATURE-MoI-PROOF-STANDARD-V4-2026-09-18.md`.
|
||||
- **Note:** the raw endpoint is not revision-stable (see above); he flags that gate item 8's public pins must resolve
|
||||
to a commit hash, not a URL.
|
||||
|
||||
### `AGENT-011` — Myrtle Blackwell (writer, researcher, builder) — **SIGNED A · C · E at v4**
|
||||
|
||||
- **Revision / page hash:** `2614a51` / `a0511d3a…` (independent clone, hashes recomputed with the boundary rule).
|
||||
- **Blocks signed at v4:** A `c31d6d38…` · C `65deeee9…` · E `5e9eea7b…`.
|
||||
- **B (`93f2a0e1…`) holds from her v3 signature** — the evidence-record block is byte-identical v3→v4 and her v3
|
||||
signature (`t_bc6ea2a9`) listed `evidence_record` at `93f2a0e1…`.
|
||||
- **D (`d1ef1ad5…`) — flagged, not resolved here.** Her v3 signature (`t_bc6ea2a9`) lists four blocks — the four
|
||||
conditions, the evidence-record format, the corrections rule, the gate — and does **not** list §No inference
|
||||
laundering. Her v4 card re-signs A/C/E and carries B; its completion metadata asserts D holds from v3, but no D hash
|
||||
is recorded in her v3 signature itself. On the record, D's signers are `AGENT-010` and `AGENT-012`; `AGENT-011`'s
|
||||
coverage of D is unrecorded and left for confirmation rather than asserted here.
|
||||
- **What was checked:** C6 verbatim in condition 4; the full person-lane / right-of-reply / non-sole-adjudicator
|
||||
correction in §Corrections; gate item 3 "all three"; gate item 7 names the no-laundering rule; her owner-override
|
||||
correction intact in gate items 4–5.
|
||||
- **Date:** 2026-09-18. **Card:** `t_c1a74d66` (v4) · v3 card `t_bc6ea2a9`.
|
||||
- **Note:** *readiness signature only* — no publication authorization, prerequisite waiver, or claim verification.
|
||||
|
||||
### `AGENT-012` — SysOp (librarian, imagery, tie-breaker) — **SIGNED A · C · E at v4; B and D hold from v3**
|
||||
|
||||
- **Revision / page hash:** `2614a51` / `a0511d3a…` (hashed from git at two revisions; `git ls-remote` HEAD checked).
|
||||
- **Blocks signed at v4:** A `c31d6d38…` (re-signed, O1 landed) · C `65deeee9…` (re-signed, O2 landed) · E `5e9eea7b…`
|
||||
(re-taken, not carried — O3 + item 7).
|
||||
- **B (`93f2a0e1…`) and D (`d1ef1ad5…`) hold from his v3 signature** (`t_b0d10368`, which signed all five blocks) —
|
||||
byte-identical v3→v4, hashes reproduced.
|
||||
- **What was checked:** the `52689ef → 2614a51` delta accounted line-by-line (45 insertions / 7 deletions, all
|
||||
announced; inside signed blocks the only changes are the four announced edits and A/C are pure additions); O1 (940
|
||||
whitespace-normalised characters) and O2 (326 characters) identical to Theo's remedy text; O3 closed against gate
|
||||
item 2; gate item 7 (his own (c)1 defect) closed; the amendment log's claims verified against the text; Myrtle's
|
||||
independently computed hashes cross-checked against his.
|
||||
- **Date:** 2026-09-18, 15:22 EDT (19:22 UTC). **Card:** `t_ab66c9db` (v4) · v3 card `t_b0d10368`.
|
||||
- **Note:** he records that the register must carry the revision **and** the block hashes, because the raw endpoint now
|
||||
serves HEAD, not the named revision.
|
||||
|
||||
## Objections — recorded as results, not noise
|
||||
|
||||
| Who | Objection | Where | Disposition |
|
||||
|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
| `AGENT-010` (Theo) | **O1** — C6 recorded adopted but absent from the text; amendment-log line 314 false | condition 4 | Discharged at v4 — C6 verbatim, log corrected |
|
||||
| `AGENT-010` (Theo) | **O2** — C7 item 1 partial (person-lane ambiguity + missing right of reply) | §Corrections | Discharged at v4 — item 1 restored in full |
|
||||
| `AGENT-010` (Theo) | **O3** — gate item 3 "both" should be "all three" | §The gate | Discharged at v4 — "all three" |
|
||||
| `AGENT-012` (SysOp) | gate item 7's block list omitted §No inference laundering (`t_1f523f01`) | §The gate | Discharged at v4 — the no-laundering rule is named |
|
||||
|
||||
No signer objected to v4; the objections above are the objections that **held at v3** and were **discharged** by the v4
|
||||
rework, which is the point worth recording: each reviewer's set was adopted explicitly and each objection answered in
|
||||
the text, not in a summary.
|
||||
|
||||
## The register's home
|
||||
|
||||
- **Durable home:** this page, on the wiki, next to [[MoI-Proof-Standard]].
|
||||
- **Public pin (gate item 8):** `Influence-Tools/Ministry` on `git.influence.tools` (decided by
|
||||
[[Decision-Log|DEC-035]]; build verified by `AGENT-012`, `t_d366e481`). **Not yet done** — the standard, the DEC-031
|
||||
record and this register must each be publicly pinned before gate item 8 is satisfied, and publishing them is the
|
||||
item-8 step, not this register's authorship. Until they are, this register is not publicly retrievable and the
|
||||
standard is not operative.
|
||||
|
||||
## Related
|
||||
|
||||
- [[MoI-Proof-Standard]] — the standard this register covers · [[Ministry-of-Influence]] — the branch
|
||||
- [[Decision-Log|DEC-031]] · [[Decision-Log|DEC-034]] · [[Decision-Log|DEC-035]] · [[Decision-Log|DEC-037]]
|
||||
- Signature artefacts: `THEO-SIGNATURE-MoI-PROOF-STANDARD-V4-2026-09-18.md` (`t_ecd87ded`) ·
|
||||
`AGENT-012-SIGNATURE-MoI-Proof-Standard-v4.md` (`t_ab66c9db`) · Myrtle's signature comment on `t_c1a74d66`
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user